969 Musings on EVMs, AAm Admi Party, etc.

A learned friend of mine has emailed me extremely timely and useful links to appreciate and understand the technical aspects of the tamperability of EVMs used by India- the World's Largest Democracy, nearly since the advent of the 21st Century in its Elections. Here are two important links to the live topic of TAMPERABILTY OF ELECTRONIC VOTING MACHINES USED IN INDIA as against the claim of the Election Commission of INdia, that Electronic Voting Machines used in India ARE ABSOLUTELY TAMPER-PROOF. yb-a-donkey's view: Audi alterim partem (Hear the other Party) seems to be missing at the Election Commission. The views of Shri Arvind Jha, an alumni of IIT Kharagpur, and Shri Hari K Prasad, deserve to be heard, and examined by a Committee of Technical Experts.

RELATED LINKS

1) Arvind Jha. Click here to go to https://www.quora.com/Why-do-technocrats-believe-that-Indian-EVMs-can-be-hacked-tampered-even-though-these-are-stand-alone-units/answer/Arvind-Jha-1. 2) Click here to go to http://linkis.com/indianexpress.com/ar/apREQ

Random / important Quotes for Review, from Related Links

“ECI doing the mistake once gain, challenging techies is like falling into their own trap.”

"...ECI shud first invite for an open security audit in EVMs to list out all vulnerable touch points for criminals and secure wrap one by one."

Though not keen to take up the EC challenge this time, Prasad continues to maintain that EVMs are vulnerable to hacking. "...EVMs without VVPAT [voter verified paper audit trail] are vulnerable"

"...No electronic machine is secure without a tangible receipt that can be verified. Electronics can always be manipulated. It’s just a matter of understanding the technology. ..."

y6b-a-donkey's views not intended to be imposed on others

There is/can be no link between the VVPAT [voter verified paper audit trail], and the vulnerability of EVMs after election, and before counting. Receipt will be useful for production as evidence in courts. But Receipts cannot prevent tampering of EVMs during their storage waiting counting. Machines may be sealed. Strong Rooms may be sealed. Yet, we cannot rule out the possibility of tampering using remote devices such as WIFI with / without the help of Officials controlling Paswords. Production of the Printed Receipt in Court will only prove the fact only for that particular vote, and that particular voter. Physical comparison of the printed receipts with the counted data file used in EVM, is physically difficult. One solution may be, that backup(s) of data in each EVM is taken and preserved separately for comparison in case of disputes.

Come what may, I am not in favor of going back to PAPER BALLOT SYSTEM, which is frought with numerous difficulties and risks when compared to EVMs. Our next step should be to go to Mobile/Laptop based Voting Systems, whereby voters can vote from their own places of work / residences at their convenient time. Of course, we have to do lots of homework and preparations to make the Internet based Mobile based Voting Systems more fool-proof, tamper-proof.

---

SELF GOALS OF MR. ARVIND KEJRIWAL

Mr. Arvind Kejriwal, AAP Chief, and the Chief Minister of Delhi seems to be passing through a poor form (common to cricketers and politicians, both of whom entertain and indulge in superstitions and consult astrologers and GodPersons), and through rough patches owing to his own self-goals.


We shall start with his frequent blaming of EVM Tampering, whenever AAP faces an Election mishap. In Feb. 2015 Elections to Delhi Assembly, his party won 67 seats out of 70. BJP was in power at that time, and it was on a winning spree right from the 2014 May General Elections. Top Leaders of BJP might have received the greatest shock of their lives, when then saw the Delhi Assembly Election Results. Prior to 2015 Delhi Assembly Elections Mr. Kejriwal conducted a rally on his apprehensions of EVM tampering. When the Election Results came in his favor, Mr. Kejriwal forgot about his own complaints of possible EVM tampering, and happily ascended his throne, like the mythological Nahusha who was heralded to become the King of Heaven 'Indra', when the incumbent Indra was cursed by Sage Durvasa. Then the arrogance of power seems to have got injected into his brain by his sycophant followers, and he alienated himself from his AAP Founding colleagues Yogendra Yadav and Prashanti Bhushan.

Actually, before anointing himself as the Chief Minister of Delhi in 2015, Mr. Kejriwal should have raised his suspicions about the most unnaturally favourable Election Result, and he ought to have voiced reiterating his doubts about the tampering of EVMs, and called for going back to paper ballots. It was a simple question of common sense. In 2014 May General Elections for Parliament, voters of Delhi gave all the seats to BJP and rejected AAP. In Feb. 2015 they lifted AAP from ashes. It should have woken up the conscience of Mr. Kejriwal, and made him to ask

"Why this sudden change of mind?"
"I have not done anything great in these seven months to deserve these Floral Showers?"
"Who tampered the EVMs through some Remote Devices?"
"Did my own techno-savvy supporters without my knowledge tamper the machines to uplift me to the Delhi throne?"
"Or did the techno-savvy supporters of BJP tamper the EVMs, to create a false belief in the minds of everybody that BJP's losing elections is a proof of in-tamper-ability of the EVMs?"
"Or did the leaders of the BJP arranged, AS A ONE TIME STRATEGY--for the tampering of EVMs to facilitate victory of AAP in 2015, to convince people that EVMs are not tamperable, so that in subsequent elections EVMs can be freely tampered whimsically, as people WILL HEREAFTER STRONGLY BELIEVE THAT EVMS are TAMPER-PROOF?"

Why does Mr. Arvind Kejriwal want to shut the mouth of Kumar Biswar from airing out his grievances? After all, people should have a sort of vent or a gasket release lever or a safety volve to flush out their inbuilt steams of frustrations and disappointments.

“I have said this multiple times to Arvind (Kejriwal) and Manish (Sisodia) and say it once again that in my life I don’t want to be the chief minister, deputy chief minister, party chief or join any other political party. I did not come here for this,” Vishwas said, while addressing press reporters in Delhi.

“I will take a decision in a day and will continue to speak up. Khan is only a mask speaking for someone else.”

ybdonkey's views:Mr. Kumar Biswas seems to have made up his mind long back to leave AAP, and (probably) join BJP. He seems to be searching for pretexts to leave. There is very little that can be done at this too late a stage. A stitch in time should have saved nine later. It is high time that Mr. Arvind Kejriwal think of retrieving his Party's INNER DEMOCRACY. Else, AAP itself may become defunct.

It will be better if Mr. Kejriwal resigns as the Chief Minister of Delhi, and allow his party to elect a new Chief Minister through democratic secret ballot methods, whoever the AAP Delhi Assembly Legislature Party may choose to elect. He should concentrate on the promotion of the Party at All India Level. Probably, he can think of re-friend-ing with Messrs. Yogendra Yadav and Prashanti Bhushan.

To continue adding / deleting / modifying. सशेष. ఇంకా ఉంది.

943 Mr. Ram Jeth Malani, Senior Supreme Court Lawyer's offering to Arvind Kejriwal, to argue freely in his defence against Finance Minister Arun Jaitley, is intriguing.

Reports indicate that Mr. Ram Jeth Malani, Senior Supreme Court Advocate, Former BJP Top Leader, Former Law Minister, has initially sent a bill of about Rs. 38 million as fees, and expenses to Mr. Arvind Kejriwal, Delhi Chief Minister. It appears that Mr. Kejriwal wanted to pay the bill from the Exchequer of the Delhi Government. There are reports which indicate that Mr. Sisodia, Delhi Dy. Chief Minister wanted the Delhi Govt. Officials to clear the bill, without sending it to the Delhi Lieutenant Governor. But, that was not so easy. Hence, according to Media Reports, Mr. Ram Jeth Malani has come forward to argue the defence of Mr. Kejriwal, FREELY treating him as a poor client. Here is a link to the report: Click here to go to http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/arvind-kejriwal-ram-jethmalani-legal-fee-arun-jaitley-case/1/919953.html.

Link to DeccanChronicle.Com, which has some additional quotes attributed to Shri Ram Jeth Malani: Click here to go to http://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/current-affairs/050417/will-defend-arvind-kejriwal-for-free-says-ram-jethmalani.html.

"...I shall defend Arvind Kejriwal in the defamation case slapped on him by Finance Minister Arun Jaitley without taking any fee if the Delhi Chief Minister cannot afford to pay him."

"...The row over the Delhi government’s move to clear my bills for fighting the case has been “instigated” by the Union finance minister".

"...it is the government’s duty to defend the Chief Minister. ...I will certainly defend him even if he can’t pay, but he said ‘no, I want to pay, send us the bills’, so I have sent the bills. Even if the government does not support him, I will. ... If necessary, I will support him for his livelihood because he is a clean force compared to Arun Jaitley, ...”

"...The bills totalled around 3.4 crore. ...If he is unable to pay I will do it for free. I render free services to 90 per cent of my clients ..."

ybrao-a-donkey's views not intended to be imposed on others:

There will be nothing wrong for a State/UT Government to defend in Courts, the actions / communications of its functionaries / officials, as long as their communications are made in their official capacities, following proper procedures, at proper fora.

If the 'defaming' comment is made by Mr. Arvind Kejriwal, in his capacity as Chief Minister of Delhi, then, it will be reasonable for him, and Mr. Ram Jethmalani to expect that its DEFENCE BILL is to be paid by the Government of Delhi. How to distinguish official comments from private personal comments?

Solution 1:

Reproduce all comments / allegations made by the Chief Minister of a State, in writing. Writings are to be made on Official Letterheads. After the affixing signature of CM, it is better to add his Office Seal. Before and above the signature of the Chief Minister, it will be better to add "For and on behalf of the Government of Delhi". In case of digital / email / electronic communications, wherever possible digital signatures and encryptions can be added. In case of oral comments / observations, an Official Videographer who should be an employee of the Delhi Government, can be employed to produce duly recorded videos, and its copies.

Approvals for Expenses

While the Chief Minister or his Dy. Chief Minister cannot be sole judges to decide on whether to bear the expenses on behalf of the State, I believe that everything cannot be centralised into the hands of the Governors / Lieutenant Governors who now-a-days act as Clerks of the Central Government.

In India, even State Cabinets tend to be slaves of Chief Ministers, and Central Cabinets tend to be the slaves of the Prime Ministers, and hence the question of defending CMs/PMs at State Expenses cannot be left to the Cabinets.

Better to obtain approvals from Legislatures

Though not a perfect solution, it will be better, if the decisions are taken by State Assemblies, and in case of Prime Ministers- by the Parliaments. For the purpose Approval Resolutions can be proposed in the Lower House, the reasons and the circumstances which have led to the legal cases can be discussed, and approval to defend the cases at the expense of State Exchequer can be given. This is on the assumption that our Legislatures will be filled with members who can view problems objectively, independent of party affiliations.

These proposals for sanction of funds to bear expenses to defend cases against Government functionaries (both politicians and bureaucrats), should as far as possible be present before the Legislatures for prior prior approval, giving approximate estimates of likely expenditure, name of the advocates proposed, break up of their fees for various purposes, other expenses etc. Only in exceptional emergencies, post facto confirmations /ratifications can be obtained from Legislatures.

CLAIM OF SHRI RAM JETHMALANI THAT 90% OF HIS CASES ARE FREE CASES ON BEHALF OF POOR

I am unable to believe it. But he is a NONAGENARIAN. Difficult to doubt him. However, I believe, as citizens, we expect him to disclose the names of the poor persons/institutions he argued FREE, with some details such as nature of dispute, year, court, success/failure etc. He can place these details on his web page / social media page. There is nothing wrong in cross-subsidisation per se (Charging the Rich, and serving the poor). Even doctors and Hospitals can do it, but they do not seem to undertake such useless things (useless things in their opinion), except in the Returns they submit to the Government, if at all they submit, when required by law.

Wherever / Whenever possible, State Assemblies can pass Resolutions ratifying the statements made by Chief Ministers.

WHY DO MANY STATE GOVERNMENTS BELIEVE THAT THEY CAN DEFEND SUCCESSFULLY/WIN CASES ONLY WHEN THEY APPOINT A HIGH PROFILE LAWYER?

Governments are supposed to be RATIONAL ORGANISATIONS. They cannot afford to be irrational, and citizens/voters will have to dump irrational Governments, when they get opportunity to vote.

Usually film producers, distributors entertain irrational beliefs that their films will rake heaps of moolah only when they make films with Mega Heroes such as Salman Khan, Shah Rukh Khan. Rajani Kanth. But Governments should not have such fallacious beliefs that they will win cases only when they employ high profile lawyers. The success of a film depends largely on its storyline, and to some extent on the treatment given to it, i.e. the manner in which it is presented to the audience. The same is the case with recipes, beverages such as coffee, tea, where tastes and flavours emerge from the quality and quantity of the ingredients used. In case of suits, their successes or failures depend on basically on 'justice is on which side'. The manner in which the Counsel presents the case may initially impress judges, but ultimately the ratio decidendi will depend on the strength of the CAUSE OF JUSTICE. Of course, evidences and arguments have their value, in affecting the judgement, but they cannot make UNJUSTIFIABLE CAUSES, JUSTIFIABLE.

Then, what is expected of/from a Counsel? What is expected from Judges?

Counsel should not be negligent or lethargic. He-she must be alert. And of course, the Judges have to give sufficient opportunities to the Counsels.

The general impression among many lawyers all over India is that :
*High profile lawyers get encouragement from Judges, while starters are treated like a Cinderella in her mother's house.
*High Profile lawyers can get their cases heard early,
*High Profile lawyers can get easy adjournments when needed.
*High profile lawyers can confuse or pressurise judges.
Etc. Etc.

COURTS HAVE TO DISPEL THE ERRONEOUS BELIEFS OF STARTER ADVOCATES

And these beliefs, may they be only misconceptions, lead to HUGE DEMAND FOR HIGH PROFILE LAWYERS, LEADING TO MILLIONS OF BUCKS THROWN AWAY BY CLIENTS AS THEIR FEES, while poor lawyers starve. It is high time that Supreme Courts and High Courts take adequate steps for dispelling this type of apprehensions among lawyers and clients. After all, Lawyers are intended only to assist the Judges in arriving at truth, and they are employees of the Court. Though fees is paid by clients, lawyers are not supposed to be the SERVANTS AND SLAVES OF THE CLIENTS.

State and Central Governments should not fall into the above type of pits, of appointing lawyers only by their name, and demand.

COURTS SHOULD APPOINT LAWYERS FOR BOTH THE PARTIES

When clients are given freedom to chose their own lawyers, rich clients chose high profile lawyers paying millions as fees. Poor clients are left with residues. The impression that High Profile Lawyers are geniuses capable of winning cases, and that low profile lawyers are duds make no sense. Heroes charge millions for acting in films, and their films bomb at box office. There are several simple straight cases argued by HIGH PROFILE LAWYERS which have failed in getting even simple remedies. This is because Lawyers do their duty. Judges do their duty. Hence, clients have to shed their foolish beliefs. Can we expect that Supreme Court/High Courts will create an environment which melts away the mists and smogs before the clients' eyes? Or will they call us to court and convict us for Contempt of Court?

To continue adding / deleting / modifying. जोडने को वस्तु हैं। ఇంకా వ్రాయాల్సినవి ఉన్నాయి.

781 We should appreciate the courage of Ms. Jagmati Sanwar in resisting CPM Central Committee

This is in continuation of our blogpost No. 758 dated 21st May 2016, wherein we have discussed some of the problems ailing the CPIM (Communist Party of India, Marxist). The title of the blogpost is: 758 CPIM is continuing the same disastrous and undemocratic practices of Congress and BJP ! Lacks internal democracy. For those who wish to study this blogpost: Click to go to 758 . Now, at least one courageous person in the CPIM Central Committee, Ms. Jagmati Sanwar, General Secretary of AIDWA has come out openly against the manner in which the CPIM Central Committee was violating its own Party-line of not having any truck with Congress, by forging alliances with Congress, in West Bengal. The debacle of CPM in the 2016 Bengal Assembly Elections, has sufficiently proved that unhealthy alliances with borgeoisie parties in the name of preventing /displacing some other bourgeoisie party do not pay. It appears that the Central Committee Members from Bengal have opposed the use of the word "violating" party-line in the Resolution of postmortem of losing the Elections in Bengal, and threatened to resign.

Here is a newsreport dated the 25th June 2016 from ndtv.com, which summarises what seems to have happened in CPIM Central Committee Meeting, and the circumstances which seem to have led to resignation of Ms. Jagmati from the Central Committee (according to her: resignation) and expulsion of Ms. Jagmati from the Central Committee (according to Party: expulsion for gross indiscipline).

Here is an Indian Express Report which informs what seems to have happened at the said Central Committee Meeting. Click to look at IndianExpress

Considering my resignation was in my opinion a step to strengthen the party, there is no question now of trying to weaken the party or any mass organisation. My decision was an entirely political decision and to interpret it as some kind of personal rivalry is absolutely wrong

This meeting started on June 18. And on the 18th the note presented by the politburo… it had this term that it was a violation of the political tactical line by the Bengal committee. And a huge majority said it was a violation... ... But today, when it concluded on the basis of the discussion… they said we will be deleting this violation word because Bengal secretary Surjya Kanta Misra and senior leaders like Bimanda [Bose] said we (they) will resign if you (cpm) keep this term. Even the general secretary [Sitaram Yechury] was against it. I said no, it is not acceptable, at least to me. I said I resign from the central committee and party membership and I walked out,

"...Considering my resignation was in my opinion a step to strengthen the party, there is no question now of trying to weaken the party or any mass organisation. My decision was an entirely political decision and to interpret it as some kind of personal rivalry is absolutely wrong . ..."

"... This meeting started on June 18. And on the 18th the note presented by the politburo… it had this term that it was a violation of the political tactical line by the Bengal committee. And a huge majority said it was a violation... ... But today, when it concluded on the basis of the discussion… they said we will be deleting this violation word because Bengal secretary Surjya Kanta Misra and senior leaders like Bimanda [Bose] said we (they) will resign if you (cpm) keep this term. Even the general secretary [Sitaram Yechury] was against it. I said no, it is not acceptable, at least to me. I said I resign from the central committee and party membership and I walked out. ..."

ybrao-a-donkey's humble comments. वैबीराव एक गधे के विनम्र राय . వైబీరావ్ గాడిద వినమ్ర వాణి. You have every right to differ with me. I respect your right. आपको मेरे मत से भिन्न राय रखने के संपूर्ण हक है। मै उस अधिकार को परिपूर्ण रूप से गौरव देता हुँ. మీకు, మీ భిన్నమైన అభిప్రాయాన్ని కలిగిఉండే సంపూర్ణ హక్కు ఉంది. దానిని ఎంతో నేను గౌరవిస్తాను. However, pl. examine this donkey's views also. परन्तु एस गधे के दृष्टिकोण को भी अनुशीलन कीजिये. కానీ ఈ గాడిద దృష్టికోణాన్ని కూడ ఓర చూపుతో కంటజూడుమీ, క్రీగంట జూడమీ.

Ms. Jagmati Sangwan has taken a courageous decision.

She need not worry about weakening Communist or Socialist Movements in India.

She can try to promote a new Communist / Socialist / Democratic Socialist Party in India, which should include not only women, but also men.

Just as there are large number of bourgeoisie political parties in India, we can have large number of Communist / Socialist / Democratic Socialist Parties. I do not support the idea of unification of Communist Parties or having only one or two Communist Parties. Such step will only lead to monopolies and oligopolies in socialist arena.

In fact, totalitarianism is the bane of Communism, worldwide. At least in India, let us make a beginning of working against and dispelling the general impression of Communism / Socialism / Marxism involves dictatorships and totalitarianism.

CPIM seems to be suffering from loss of geographical spread. It sems to be excessively depending on its West Bengal and Kerala Units. For the time being it may be strong in West Bengal and Kerala. But CPIM Central Leadership should not forget that theirs is an All India Party, with defined set of principles. Opportunism and Regionalism cannot have places and prominence in the principles and party-lines. At any cost, inner party democracy cannot be sacrificed, in the name of gross indiscipline. One tool for deriving benefits from inner party democracy is through use of secret ballots at every level, where everything will be put to test through secret ballots, with a clear understanding that loss of something in ballot is not an end in itself, and after sometime, another attempt can be made.

PROBLEMS OF RELIANCE ON ONE OR TWO STATES

Mr. Jayaprakash Narayan, a Retd. I.A.S. Officer had started a Party by name Lok Satta. As JPN is from erstwhile United Andhra Pradesh, it had a good base in defunct United A.P.

Later, he wanted to convert Lok Satta into an All India Party, with Office at Delhi. Mr. JPN seems to have had some dreams of developing his party on the lines of A.A.P.

A.A.P (Aam Admi Party) too have dreams of emerging as an All India Party. But its base is only in Delhi and Punjab.

Already there are divisions and splits in A.A.P., culminating in expulsion of Yogendra Yadav, Prashanti Bhushan et al. Now, AAP (Kejriwal) is still continuing with its dreams. If Mr. Kejriwal inserts more South Indian leaders into AAP Central Committee, there is always a danger of revolt from Delhi and Punjab leaders, whose sweat the successes of AAP in Delhi and Punjab, which Mr. Kejriwal enjoys.

Back to Lok Satta, one gets an impression that Shri JPN wanted to give a greater role to his Delhi Associates, which seems to have been resisted by the A.P. Lok Satta Leaders. It appears that Mr. JPN wanted to have his say as founder of the party. Somehow, things did not workout, and the party seems to have been shelved or inactive.

ONE SOLUTION

It will be better if parties in India are organised NOT ON THE BASIS OF GEOGRAPHICAL UNITS, but ON THE BASIS OF DIFFERENT CLASSES OF PROLETARIAT such as farm workers, fishermen, rural artisans, metal workers, shop clerks, street vendors, construction workers, etc. etc. The different classes can be made of equal representation, size, by expert studies of various occupations and profession in India.

At grassroot level, units need not be organised in the traditional mode of village units, ward level units, or polling booth level units. Parties can take every group of 10 members of the same occupation/profession as one grassroot unit, and its leader can be called "daSamukh". A leader of ten such groups can be called "Satamukh". Ten Satamukhs can make a Sahasramukh. Thus leaderships and structures have to rise from bottom to the top, through a system of secret ballots.

NOT EASY TO START AND RUN NEW POLITICAL PARTIES IN INDIA

It is not easy to start and run new political parties in India, both bourgeoisie and Socialist. While the bourgeoisie parties may do anything they like because they need not worry about ethics, Socialist Parties have to explore ways and means of organising parties without COSTS. CPIM has recently organised a motorcycle rally in Vijayawada. Who will pay the cost of petrol? Party workers participating in such rallies will lose one day wages, they have to bear the cost of petrol, they have to neglect their families. For its Meeting at Vijayawada, CPIM might have collected funds from somebody or other without verifying their source of income. For example, there is an allegation against CPI that it collected donations from Liquor Contractors in Khammam District for organising its Meeting there.

Workers and Proletarian Parties have greater ethical responsibilities when compared to Mainline parties.

To continue. सशेष. ఇంకా ఉంది.

743 Better late than Never. It is good that Gujarat University Vice Chancellor clarified about PM's M.A. Degree.

This is in continuation of blogpost No.569 (Click to go to 569). English language has a proverb: "Better late than never!". We should be grateful to the Information Commissioner Mr. M. Sridharacharyulu, and the Gujarat University Vice Chancellor Mr. M.N. Patel, for bringing to a near-close, the issue of allegations about the fact of our beloved Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi, obtaining a PG Degree of M.A. Politics. Here is an ND TV News Report (Click to go to ND TV.com to see the news.) which indicates that Shri Modi completed his M.A. Politics Degree in 1983, scoring 62.3%.

Delhi CM wanted details of PM Modi's education to be made public PM Modi, in 2014 polls, declared he had a BA and a Master's degree Haven't been asked to share details: Gujarat University Vice Chancellor.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi completed his post-graduation in Political Science from the Gujarat University with a 62.3% score, Vice Chancellor MN Patel has said amid a row over Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal accusing the Central Information Commission of covering up the PM's educational qualifications. Earlier this week, Mr Kejriwal had demanded that this information be made public by the CIC.

The Vice Chancellor has however told NDTV that the university hasn't been approached by anyone seeking this information yet. He also added that the university had earlier turned down the request since rules allowed only individual candidates to seek details of their marks. "For instance X cannot seek details of Y and that is why we had turned down the RTI request. Now that the CIC has issued an order, we will provide details if asked to," he said.

ybrao-a-donkey's humble comments. वैबीराव एक गधे के विनम्र राय . వైబీరావ్ గాడిద వినమ్ర వాణి. You have every right to differ with me. I respect your right. आपको मेरे मत से भिन्न राय रखने के संपूर्ण हक है। मै उस अधिकार को परिपूर्ण रूप से गौरव देता हुँ. మీకు, మీ భిన్నమైన అభిప్రాయాన్ని కలిగిఉండే సంపూర్ణ హక్కు ఉంది. దానిని ఎంతో నేను గౌరవిస్తాను. However, pl. examine this donkey's views also. परन्तु एस गधे के दृष्टिकोण को भी अनुशीलन कीजिये. కానీ ఈ గాడిద దృష్టికోణాన్ని కూడ ఓర చూపుతో కంటజూడుమీ, క్రీగంట జూడమీ.

As the matter has been cleared by a Competent Authority, we can treat the matter as closed, for the time being. Let us hope that Mr. Arvind Kajriwal also will treat the matter as closed, unless he has some other evidence to doubt the disclosure made by the Vice Chancellor, Gujarat University.

BETTER LATE THAN NEVER, EARLIER DISCLOSURE WOULD HAVE BEEN FAR BETTER

This controversy arose in and around in Aug. 2015. Had this information been furnished by the Gujarat University in Aug 2015 itself or at some other early date, without waiting for instruction of Mr. Sridharacharyulu (Information Commissioner), lot of Media Space and Time could have been saved. People would have had peace of mind at least eight months earlier. By withholding information which ought to have been kept in public domain, giving some technical excuse such as non-availability of Roll No., what did the University gain?

LET US HOPE THAT REGIONAL PASSPORT OFFICER, AHMEDABAD, ALSO CLEARS THE PASSPORT APPLICATION OF MS. JASHODA BEN

It appears that Ms. Jashoda Ben w/o our PM Shri Narendra Modi wanted to go abroad and applied for a passport. Media reports indicate that her application has been rejected on some flimsy ground like 'marriage declaration /certificate not submitted'. Unless there are extremely valid reasons, it will be apt for the Regional Passport Officer, to clear her application also, without waiting for instructions from Information Commissioner. Justice should not only be done, it should also appear to have been done. If Regional Passport Officer withholds the passport application of Ms. Jashoda Ben, on some flimsy ground, there is a risk of our Prime Minister getting a bad name.

Subject to corrections and deletions. To continue. सशेष. ఇంకా ఉంది.

712 Congress and Mr. Arvind Kejriwal should stop this blaming game! It does not really help them, or India.

Congress Party through its Official Spokesperson Mr. Abhishekh Singhwi, and A.A.P. through its leader Mr. Arvind Kejriwal, threw some mud on BJP and Mr. Narendra Modi, for allowing an Investigation Team from Pakisthan to visit India and Pathankot, which unfortunately turned out to be a damp squib. Suppose, if Congress or A.A.P. is in power, and BJP is in opposition at Centre, will Mr. Narendra Modi have thrown more mud or less mud on the Govt. ? Considering his performance, he will throw more mud on the Congress for the fiasco. This is not a hypothetical question. It is more a question on the behavioral trends of bourgeoisie political parties all over the world. Neither Congress or BJP cannot be exceptions to the Universal Trends.

Clarification from ybrao-a-donkey: I am not a supporter of Congress or BJP or A.A.P. Though, I am trying for an intellectual paradigm shift of Indians in general towards a leftist sland, I do not spare even left parties like CPM and CPI, which have their leftist mask on their boureoisie interior.

Question: Is the mutual mud-slinging among A.A.P., Congress and BJP on the Pathankot fox pos really relevant from the point of view of Marxism or Communism or Socialism?

Ans: What I am worried about in 2016 India, is the future of Proletariat (Working Class in general, and unorganised Working Class in particular), in this Nation (or country?) of 1.3 billion ants or bees.

Terrorism is a common problem both for India and Pakisthan. The problem of Pakistan seems to be while the elected Government either on its own volition or under pressure from its principal benefactor United States, occasionally offers its helping hand to India for overcoming Cross-border terrorism, the Pakisthan Army, Police, investigative arm ISI, seem to support cross-border terrorism in India.

Suppose if the Pakistan Government functionaries instruct the Pakisthani Army, Police, ISI to co-operate with India in its fight against terrorism, they say "yes" to the Government superficially, and sabotage the investigations from behind. Hence, there is no wonder if the Pakistani Investigation Team which visited India went back and said that India did not help, and blamed India.

As a matter of fact, there is a lot of investigation to be done in Pakisthani territory. As a Sovereign State, Pakistan ought to have done it, prosecuted the culprits who attacked Pathankot Airbase, and got them convicted in their courts of Law. But, that is an ideal situation which seldom happens.

Apart from the unwillingness of the Pak Bureaucracy, Police, ISI, Army to co-operate, there are two more hitches. 1. Corruption and inefficiency. 2. Variance between laws, investigation procedures prevalent in Pakistan and in India.

It will not be polite or prudent for India to say that Pakistani Investigative Agencies are inefficient. For that matter, in some respects, even Indian Investigative Agencies are inefficient.

Still, if Mr. Nawaz Sheriff wants continue extending his helping hand, he can permit Indian Investigating Agencies to continue their investigating work in Pakistani Territory, subject to some conditions. Of course, Pakistani Investigating Agencies will object to it. They will not co-operate.

Right now, there is no use of Indian Political Parties and their leaders indulging in a blaming game. Even if they are not willing to provide constructive co-operation and suggestions, they can maintain silence. They can leave Mr. Narendra Modi and his Cabinet to tackle the problem to the best of their ability upto 2019. They (Opposition) may get their turn in 2019. Till then, they have to wait. There is no alternative.

In cricket for example, a batsman who is duck-out in his first innings, will be too eager to score a Century in the second innings. If he-she ducks in both the innings, then the player have to wait for another match/Test. If in most matches/tests they fail, then they have to wait for the next Series. Some unfortunate players may get only one or two opportunities. Some others like Mr. Sachin Tendulkar may get numerous opportunities in spite of repeated failures. If an ordinary sport like Cricket has so many vicissitudes , how many wageries the gambles of politics should have?

Bureaucrats and Politicians governing India can ask the Indian Intelligence and Investigating Agencies, Army, Paramilitary Officials (NIA, CBI, BSF, etc.) to workout some reasonable solutions.

In the mean time, India will have to erect a second inner fence on the Indo Pak Border, to double filter insurgents. There is also a need to deploy more drones, Lakshya aircraft, reconnoissance radars, surveillance systems.

To continue. सशेष. ఇంకా ఉంది.

461 Kejriwal Group has driven out Yadav and Bhushan as expected

The political affairs Committee of AAP has been authorised to take disciplinary action against:

"Any member who, without authorisation, issues media statements against the party line  and takes decisions in a bid to tarnish the party's image."

ybrao-a-donkey's humble view वैबीराव एक गधे के विनम्र राय వైబీరావ్ గాడిద వినమ్ర వ్యాఖ్య
Mr. Yogendra Yadav and Mr. Prashanti Bhushan need not hang around and fall down at the feet of Mr. Kejriwal.  योगींद्र यादव और प्रशांति भूषण दिल्ली में कसमसने के, बेकार घूमने के जरूरत नहीं है।  वे केज्रीवाल के पाँवों पर गिरने का जरूरत नहीं है।  శ్రీ యోగీంద్ర యాదవ్, శ్రీ ప్రశాంతి భూషణ్ లు ఢిల్లీలో వేలాడుతూ, కేజ్రీవాల్ పాదాల దగ్గర పడి ఉండటం, లేక అతగాడిని గిల్లుతూ ఉండే కన్నా, దక్షిణాదికి వచ్చి తమ సేవలనందిస్తే ఉత్తమంగా ఉంటుంది.

They can leave Kejriwal and the People of Delhi to look after their own affairs.  वे केज्रीवाल और दिल्ली जनता को, अपने समस्याओं को समालने के लिये छोड सकते हैं।  వాళ్ళు కెజ్రీవాల్ ను, ఢిల్లీ ప్రజలను, తమ సమస్యలను తాము పరిష్కరించుకోటానికి వదలివేయటం మేలు.

Yadav and Bhushan can start a new NATIONAL party from the State of Residual Andhra Pradesh.  They can start their reconstruction, and battle against corruption (for the time being , assuming that they are genuine crusaders against corruption) from Telugu Land on a fresh slate.  The people are full tired of the corrupt regimes in the United Andhra Pradesh and the Residual Andhra Pradesh.  But, it will not be easy for Yadav and Bhushan to germinate and sprout in Residual A.P.  politics without distributing liquor and making false promises.   Though Hindi land and Kurukshetra are important, they should also realise that without conquering Telugu land, they will have great difficulty in having access to Delhi throne.  

यादव और भूषण शेषीभूत आंध्र प्रदेश में एक नये पार्टी शुरू कर सकते हैं।  वे, यहाँ उनके पुनर निर्माण और , भ्रष्ठाचार व्यतिरेक समरों को यहाँ नये पटिया पर लांच कर सकते है।  प्रस्तुत के लिये, हम उनको भ्रष्ठाचार के खिलाफ असली योध मानने में कुय़ नहीं जायेगा।  उनके असली स्वरूप बाद में पता चल जायॆगा।  यहाँ के लोग भूतपूर्व समैक्य आंध्र प्रदेश और आज के शेषीभूत आंध्र प्रदेश के अविनीत पार्टियों से थक गये हुये हैं।  हिंदी लेंड मुख्य है, फिर भी, तॆलुगु लेंड को जीतने के बिना, उनको दिल्ली सिंहासन पकडना सुलभ नहीं होगा।   लेकिन, भूषण और यादव को यहां बगर मद्य और कॆन्सी बाँटने के बिना, उगना और अंकुर होना आसान नहीं होगा । 

యోగీంద్ర యాదవ్ మరియు ప్రశాంతి భూషణ్ లు తమ కొత్త జాతీయ పార్టీని శేషాంధ్ర ప్రదేశ్ నుండే ప్రారంభించ వచ్చు.  వాళ్ళు తమ పునర్ నిర్మాణ కార్యక్రమాన్ని, అవినీతి వ్యతిరేక పోరాటాన్ని కొత్త పలకపై, ఆంధ్ర ప్రదేశ్ నుండే ప్రారంభించ వచ్చు.  ఇక్కడి ప్రజలు కూడ గత ఉమ్మడి ఆం.ప్ర. మరియు ఇప్పటి శేష్ ఆంధ్ర ప్రదేశ్ అధికార ప్రతిపక్షాలు రెండిటితోకూడ బాగా అలిసిపోయి ఉన్నారు.  హిందీ భూమి ముఖ్యమే, కాని తెలుగు భూమిపై పట్టు సాధించకుండా, యదుభూషణ్ లకు ఇంద్రప్రస్థ సింహాసనం తేలికగా దొరకదు.  అంతేకాదు ఆంధ్రప్రదేశ్ ప్రజలకు మద్యం, నోట్లు పంచకుండా, ఇక్కడ చీపురుతో ఊడ్చటం సులభం కాదు.

To continue.  ससेष.  ఇంకా ఉంది.

420 Will God see that Bedi and Kejriwal lose their elections if they do not visit prayer houses?

Ms. Kiran Bedi, India's first woman IPS Officer, Chief Minister aspirant on behalf of BJP in the recent 2015 Feb. Delhi elections, is reported to have said:-

"...I am not doing it for the first time. I used to visit gurudwaras in Amritsar when I was a child. I used to go to church in my school. I believe in all religions. I learnt the 'sarva dharma' during my childhood. It's all upto God now. ..."

ybrao a DONKEY'S VOICE

What was she doing between her childhood and her candidature for the Delhi CM post?


Mr. Arvind Kejriwal, A.A.P. leader, and Delhi CM aspirant is reported to have said:-

".....Will go to all temples and gurudwaras in my constituency today. I pray to God that let truth triumph and let the common man win ..."

Accordingly he is reported to have gone to Mr. Kejriwal is reported to have visited Gurudwara Rakabganj and Birla Temple, New Delhi.


ybrao DONKEY'S VOICE

Both Bedi and Kejriwal seem to lack self-confidence.  OK.   Suppose, they do not visit the Gurudwaras and temples.  Will they lose their elections?  Suppose, all the candidates of all the parties (except Communists) go to prayer houses of all religions.  Only Bedi and Kejriwal remain in home.  Will God see that these two are defeated, for their disobedience? 

Actually, even after getting clean majority, post of the Chief Minister of any State can be a virtual hell.  Because States are beggars at the gate of Union Finance Minister for alms.  Chief Ministers without money (probable exception KCR in Telangana, with Hyderabad City in his kitty) will have to perform Kuchipudi or Kathak dance before people.


Marxists and leftists should develop leaders from their grassroots, who do not visit churches, gurudwaras, masjids and temples.

210 Fall of Kejriwal and my inner tumult

210 కేజ్రీవాల్ పతనము మరియు నా అంతరంగ మథనము.

చర్చనీయాంశాలు: అరవింద్ కేజ్రీవాల్, నరేంద్రమోడీ, Arvind Kejriwal, Varanasi, మతతత్వము

---

భారత్ లో లౌకికవాదానికి చావుదెబ్బ గాంధీ గారి కాలంలో నే తగిలింది. ఆయన స్వాతంత్ర్యోద్యమానికి ముస్లిం పెద్దల మద్దతు కూడగట్టుకోటానికి ఖిలాఫత్ ఉద్యమాన్ని బలపరచమని ప్రజలను కోరారు. ఖలీఫా అనే ఆయన టర్కీ దేశానికి అనువంశిక సుల్తాను లేక చక్రవర్తి. మొదటి ప్రపంచ యుధ్ధానంతరం, బ్రిటీష్ వారు ఖలీఫాగారి అధికారానికి ఎసరు పెట్టారు. దానికి వ్యతరేకంగా ఇస్లామిక్ ప్రపంచంలో ఖిలాఫత్ ఉద్యమం రేగింది. భారతీయులలో తురుష్కముస్లిములకు ఖలీఫా యందు భక్తి ఉండటాన వారు కూడ ఖిలాఫత్ ఉద్యమంలో చేరారు. గాంధీగారు అనుకున్నదేమిటంటే ఖిలాఫత్ కు భారతీయులు మద్దతిస్తే భారతీయ ముస్లింలు భారత స్వాతంత్ర్యోద్యమంలో ఉత్సాహంగా పాల్గొంటారని. అలా జరిగిందా, లేదా, అనటానికి చరిత్రలో సరియైన లెక్కలులేవు.

ప్రజలు మతం కోణంలో ఆలోచించటానికి పునాది గట్టిపడింది అని మటుకు చెప్పచ్చు.

నా దృష్టిలో హిందూమత తత్వం గట్టిపడటానికి కూడ , ఇది అవకాశం ఇచ్చింది.

స్వాతంత్ర్యానంతరం కూడ కాంగ్రెస్ , ఆతరువాత ఏర్పడ్డ పలు పార్టీలు మైనారిటీల రక్షణ నెపంతో ప్రజలను విభజించి పాలించటం మొదలుపెట్టారు.

ఫలితంగా హిందూమత వాద పార్టీలకుకూడ హిందువులు మద్దతివ్వటం ఎక్కువయింది.

2014 ఎన్నికలలో సోనియా గాంధీగారు ఢిల్లీ ఇమాం బుఖారీ గారిని కలిసి వోట్లు యాచించటాన్ని మనం తప్పు పట్టుకున్నాం.

ఇదే పధ్ధతిలో మోడీ గారు హిందూ సన్యాసులను ఆశ్రయించి వోట్లు అడుక్కోటాన్ని తప్పు పట్టుకున్నాం.

ఇపుడు అరవింద్ కెజ్రీవాల్ గారు చేసింది ఏమిటి? కోడలుకి బుధ్ధి చెప్పి అత్త తెడ్డునాకినట్లయింది.
కెజ్రీవాల్ గారు వారణాసిలో నామినేషన్ వేయటానికి అడుగుబెట్టగానే చేసిందేమిటి? బెనారస్ శహర్ ఈ కాజీ (బెనారస్ పట్టణానికి ముస్లిం మత న్యాయమూర్తి వంటివాడు) ఘులాం నశీర్ గారిని కలిసి ఆయన మద్దతును అడుక్కున్నారు. నసీర్ గారు కేజ్రీవాల్ గారి విజయానికి ప్రార్ధనలు చేస్తానని వాగ్దానం చేశారుట.

నా దృష్టిలో కెజ్రీవాల్ గారు చేసినది చాల చెత్త పని. ముస్లిం వోట్లకోసం బిచ్చమెత్తటం అంటే ప్రజలను మతపరంగా విడగొట్టినట్లే. అపుడు, మోడీగారు హిందూ వోట్లకోసం బిచ్చమెత్తటాన్ని తప్పు పట్టలేం.

ప్రజలంతా మతం ప్రాతిపదికగా వోట్లు వేయటం మొదలు పెట్తే, మోడీ విజయం తథ్యమవుతుంది.

శ్రీ కేజ్రీవాల్ గారి పధ్ధతి వొళ్ళో పెడుదునా , దళ్ళో పెడుదునా అన్నట్లుగా ఉన్నది. మోడీ పరిస్థితికి ఏవిధంగానూ తీసిపోటంలేదు. ఇరువురూ కామాతురాణాం న భయం న లజ్జా అన్నట్లుగా ప్రవర్తిస్తున్నారు.

శ్రీకేజ్రీవాల్ పతనం, భారత ప్రజలను తీవ్రనిరాశకు గురి చేస్తుంది. ఆటో డ్రైవర్లు, మొ|| నిమ్న వర్గాలవారు కెజ్రీవాల్ పై ఎన్నో ఆశలు పెట్టుకుని ఉన్నారు. ఏదో విధంగా మోడీని ఓడించి గయంట్ కిల్లర్ గా నమోదు కావాలనే దురాశ వల్ల కేజ్రీవాల్ సిధ్ధాంతాలు లేని ఒక అవకాశవాదిగా, చౌకబారు రాజకీయనేతగా దిగజారిపోతున్నాడు.

కేజ్రీవాల్ సిధ్ధాంతాలకు కట్టుబడి ఉంటే, ఒక దీపం మరొక దీపాన్ని వెలిగించినట్లుగా ఆయన ప్రారంభించిన ఉద్యమం చిరకాలం నిలుస్తుంది. ఆయన ప్రధాన మంత్రికాక పోయినా, ఒక సజీవమైన ఉద్యమం జాతికి స్ఫూర్తిదాయకంగా నిల్చేది.

186 Varanasi Kejriwal

186 Varanasi Kejriwal

discussion topics, చర్చనీయాంశాలు, चर्चांश: नरेंद्रमोडी, अरविंद केज्रीवाल, నరేంద్రమోడీ, Narendra Modi, Arvind Kejriwal, Varanasi, అరవింద్ కేజ్రీవాల్, వారణాసి, वारणासी

వారణాసి ప్రజలు ఆమోదిస్తే శ్రీ అరవింద్ కేజ్రీవాల్ వారణాసి నుండి శ్రీ నరేంద్ర మోడీకి ఎదురుగా పోటీచేస్తారట.

Shri Aravind Kejriwal is ready to contest from VaraNasi against Shri Narendra Modi, if people of VaraNasi express their willingness to accept him (Shri Kejriwal).

श्री अरविंद केजरीवाल श्री नरॆंद्र मोडी के खिलाफ, वाराणसी से चुनाव लड़ने के लिए तैयार है। लेकिन एक शर्त। वाराणसी के लोग केज्रीवालजी को स्वीकार करने के लिए इछ्छा व्यक्त करना।

वैबीराव् गधे का विचार धारा ybrao a donkey's thoughts వైబీరావు గాడిద ఆలోచనలు

శ్రీ నరేంద్ర మోడీ కన్నా శ్రీ అరవింద్ కేజ్రీవాల్ మెరుగైన నేతలాగా కనిపిస్తున్నాడు. నేను పొరపాటు పడి ఉండచ్చు.

Mr. Arvind Kejriwal appears to be a leader, better than Mr. Narendra Modi. I might have erred.

मेरे ख्याल में श्री अरविंद् कॆज्रीवाल नरेंद्र मोडी से एक बेहतर् नेता प्रतीत हो रहे है। मै गलत सोचा होगा।

To continue. ఇంకా ఉంది. सशेष्.

184 Aravind Kejriwal & Media

184 Aravind Kejriwal & Media

ఎజెండా, Agenda, कार्यसूची: Arvind Kejriwal,AAP,Media, Gujarat,NarendraModi,BJP, అరవింద్ కెజ్రీవాల్,ఆమ్ ఆద్మీ, మీడియా

85 లక్షల జనాభాతో , ౯౦% అక్షరాస్యతతో, గార్డెన్ సిటీగా ఖ్యాతి చెందిన బెంగుళూరు రోడ్ షోలో, ఆం ఆద్మీ పార్టీ నేత శ్రీ అరవింద్ కెజ్రీవాల్ గారు ఏమన్నారో చూడండి.
Show the 'true story' of Narendra Modi-ruled Gujarat. నరేంద్రమోడి పాలిత గుజరాత్ యొక్క అసలు కథను చిత్రించండి. नरेंद्र मोदी शासित गुजरात की 'सच्ची कहानी' दिखाइए, बताइए.
My "will jail media" statement was made with reference to "specific media houses". మీడియాను జైలుకు పంపుతాను అన్న నా ప్రకటన, కొన్ని మీడియా సంస్థలను మాత్రమే ఉద్దేశించినది. मेरा ''मीडिया को जैला भेजता हूँ'' बयान चयनित् मीडिया घरानों कॆ लिये उद्देशित है.
"My statement should not be generalised. I did not say that the entire media is corrupt," నా ప్రకటనను అందరికీ వర్తింప చేయకండి. మొత్తం మీడియా అవినీతిమయం అని నేను అనలేదు. मेरे बयान का सामान्यीकरण नहीं किया जाना चाहिए. मैं, पूरी मीडिया भ्रष्ट नहीं कहा.

మీడియాకి రాజకీయవాదులకు గల బదులుకు బదులు quid pro quo బంధాన్ని న్యాయ స్థానంలో నిరూపించటానికి చాల కష్టపడాలిసి వస్తుంది. మీడియా డైరక్టుగా లంచాలు తీసుకోటం అరుదు. అవి ఫుల్ పేజీ ప్రకటనల రూపంలో తమ ప్రతిఫలాన్ని పొందుతాయి. ఉదాహరణకి నరేంద్రమోడీ గారి గుజరాత్ ప్రభుత్వం పలు అతిభారీ పూర్తిపేజీ ప్రకటనలను దక్షిణ భారత దేశ పత్రికలకు విడుదల చేసింది. గుజరాత్ ప్రభుత్వ గొప్పతనాన్ని భారీ గుజరాతీ ఖర్చుతో దక్షిణ భారత ప్రజలకి చెప్పటం ఎందుకు? ఎందుకంటే, తన ప్రధాని పదవి ప్రచారాస్త్రంగా ఈప్రకటనలు పనికి వస్తాయి. పత్రికల, టీవీ ఛానళ్ళ నోరు మూయించవచ్చు.

ఇదే పని కాంగ్రెస్ ప్రభుత్వాలు కూడ చేస్తున్నాయి. ఆం ఆద్మీ ప్రభుత్వం కూడ, అధికారంలోకి వస్తే చేస్తుంది.

ప్రింట్ మీడియా అయినా, ఎలక్ట్రానిక్ మీడియా అయినా బ్రతుకు ప్రకటనల మీద ఆధారపడి ఉంటుంది. ఇది పెట్టుబడిదారీ విధానపు చేదునిజం.

ముద్రణా యంత్రాలెవరిస్తారు? కంప్యూటర్ హార్డవేర్ లు , సాఫ్ట్ వేర్ లు ఎవరిస్తారు? కాగితాలెవరిస్తారు?? సిరా ఎవరిస్తారు??? రిపోర్టర్లకు, సంపాదకులకు, సాంకేతిక ఉద్యోగులకు జీతాలెవరిస్తారు???? విద్యుత్ బిల్లులెవరు కడ్తారు? ఫోన్ బిల్లులెవరు కడ్తారు? రవాణా ఛార్జీలెవరిస్తారు?

Who will give expensive machinery? Who will give computer hardware and software? Who will give printing paper? Who will supply printing ink? Who will pay salaries to reporters, editors and technical staff? Who will pay electricity bills? Who will pay transport charges?

महन्गी मॆशीनरी कौन देगा? कंप्यूटर् हार्डवेर् और साफ्टवेर् कौन देगा? प्रिंटिंग् पेपर् कौन देगा? प्रिंटिंग् इंक कौन देगा? कौन पत्रकारों, संपादकों और तकनीकी कर्मचारियों को वेतन का भुगतान करेगा? बिजली बिल कौन भरेगा? परिवहन खर्च और शुल्क कौन भुग्तान् करेगा?

వైబీరావు గాడిద వ్యాఖ్యలు ybrao a donkey's views वैबीराव एक गधे के विचारधारा

శ్రీ అరవింద్ కేజ్రీవాల్ గారు పెట్టుబడిదారీ విధానాన్ని అర్ధం చేసుకోవాలి. పెట్టుబడిదారీ విధానం ఫ్రేం వర్కులో రాజకీయ పార్టీలు పని చేస్తున్నా ఈతరహా లంచగొండి తనం అనివార్యం. ఉదాహరణకి 20,000 రూ. ఇచ్చి టికెట్ కొన్న వాళ్ళకే కేజ్రీవాల్ గారితో భోజనావకాశం. 200 మంది కెజ్రీ విందుకి హాజరు అయ్యారుట.

Shri Kejriwal may please have to understand the working of the Capitalist System of Economy. This type of corruption of various institutions (not only Media) working within the framework of Capitalism, becomes inevitable, by virtue of the very nature of the Capitalist philosophy of working to make bucks.

నా దగ్గర 20,000 లేకపోతే నేను కేజ్రీవాల్ గారి ప్రక్క భోజనం చేయలేను. చెత్తకుండీలో కుక్క పక్కన భోజనం చేయాల్సిందే.

కెజ్రీవాల్ సార్ పత్రికలు, టీవీఛానల్స్ ఏ కఠిన పరిస్థితులలో వ్యాపారాలు చేస్తాయో తెలిసిన వాడే. తెలియనట్లు మాట్లాడటం ఎందుకు? Mr. Kejriwal is a person who knows all the dire circumstances under which media houses operate. Why does he speak, as if he does not know anything? मीडिया घर किस कठिन परिस्थितियों के तहत काम करते हैँ, श्री केज्रीवाल जाननेवाला आदमी है. फिर भी वे अल्पज्ञ कै जैसा क्यों बात कर रहे हैं ?

కొన్ని మీడియా సంస్థలు చేసే తప్పుడు పనులను సమర్ధించటం నా లక్ష్యంకాదు. It is not my intention to support the dirty tricks indulged in by some mediahouses. मीडिया घरानों के गंदी कामों को समर्धन करना मेरा इरादा नहीँ है.

గాజు గదులలో నివసించే వాళ్ళు రాళ్ళు విసరకూడదంటారు. ఈ సూత్రం మీడియాకూ వర్తిస్తుంది, కేజ్రీవాల్ జీ కీ వర్తిస్తుంది. They say that those who stay in glasshouses should not throw stones at others. This principle applies both to Mr. Kejriwal and the Media. जनता कहते हैँ सीसे के घरों मे रहनेवाले लोग् बाहरवाले लोगों पर पथ्थर नहीँ फेंकना चाहीए. इस सिद्धांत श्री केजरीवाल और मीडिया दोनों को लागू होता है.

Question ప్రశ్న सवाल्

మీకు తెలిసిన హిందీ, ఇంగ్లీషు స్వల్పమే అయినా మూడు భాషలలో వ్రాయటానికి ఎందుకు ప్రయాస పడుతున్నారు? Why you are you taking troubles to write in three languages, when you know little English and Hindi? आप छोटे से अंग्रेजी और हिंदी जानते हैं. फिर भी क्यों आप तीन भाषाओं में लिखने के लिए परेशान हो रहे हैं?

జవాబు reply जवाब : బి టెక్ ఎం టెక్ లు చదివిన వాళ్ళకి కూడ ఇంగ్లీషు ప్రావీణ్యం ఉండటంలేదని , అందుకే మేము ఉద్యోగాలు ఇవ్వలేక పోతున్నామని (ఉంటే ఉద్యోగాలు పంచి పెట్టినట్లు), ఐటీ కంపెనీలు కోతలు కోస్తున్నాయి.

IT Companies are boasting that even those who studied B. Tech and M. Tech do not have adequate English skills and that consequently, they are unable to employ more people (as if they will throw away jobs, if candidates with English skills are available in abundance).

మరి హిందీలో కూడా ఎందుకు కూడ వ్రాస్తున్నారు?

Then, why are you writing in Hindi also?

तो आप हिन्दी में भी क्यों लिख रहे हैं?

జవాబు reply जवाब: ఒక సీమాంధ్ర కాంగ్రెస్ నాయకుడు అన్నాడు. ''మాకు హిందీ సరిగా రానందు వల్ల మేము అధిష్ఠానం ముందు మా వాదనలను, బాధలను, ఎప్పటికప్పుడు సరిగా వినిపించుకోలేకపోయాము. తెలంగాణ వారికి హిందీ బాగా వచ్చు. కనుక వారు అధిష్ఠానం ముందు తరచుగా, సమర్ధవంతంగా తమ బాధలను, వాదనలను బాగా వినిపించుకో గలిగారు.'' దీనిని బట్టి నాకు అర్ధం అయ్యింది ఏమిటంటే సీమాంధ్ర నేతలకు, కాంగ్రెస్ వారికే కాక అన్ని పార్టీల వారికి కూడ ఇంగ్లీషు, హిందీ తొక్కిడి బాగా అవసరం. ఉడతా భక్తిగా నా వంతు సహాయం చేద్దామని.

One Seemandhra leader said. '' We could not present our problems and arguments effectively before our leaders at Delhi because we are not proficient in Hindi. Telangana people know Hindi very well. They could quite frequently and effectively present their problems and arguments before High Command and convice them to get what they wanted."

I (ybrao a donkey) understood from the above that all Seemandhra leaders of all parties (not only Congress leaders) need frequent works-out in English and Hindi. I wanted to contribute, according to might.

ऎक सीमांध्र लीडर ने कहां: ''हमारे को हिन्दी निपुणता ऒर् कमाल कम है. इसीलिये हम, हमारे समस्याऒं, बाधाओं, वादनाऒं को हैकमांड् के सामने अछ्छी तरह प्रजॆंट् नहीं कर सके. तॆलंगाणा नेताओं को हिन्दी मे प्रवीणता औरा कुशलता ज्यादा है. इसीलिये उन् नेता अधिष्ठान के सामने अपने विचार विमर्शों को अछ्ची तरह विवरण को विस्तार से कई बार करकॆ अधिष्ठान को अपने ऒर् खींच लिये.''

यह सुनने का बाद् मै (वैबीरावु ऎक् गधा) सोचा था. सिर्फ कांग्रॆस् के नेता नहीं , सीमांध्र के सभी पार्टीयों के नेताओं को अंग्रॆजी और हिन्दी का अभ्यास, कसरत और मॆहनत होना चाहिए. मै भी अपना क्षमता के अनुसार, कोशिस कर के, सीमांध्र प्रजा को मदद करना शुरु किया.

मेरा आकांक्षा है कि, सीमांध्र के जनता को अखिल भारतीय वाणिज्य या नोकरी करने का समय पर, यह निपुणता काम मे आयेगा. अंग्रेजी निपुणता विदेशी वाणिज्य या नोकरी करने का समय पर काम मे आयेगा.

మనం అంతా తెలుగులో వ్రాసుకుంటే, మన ఆందోళన (లొల్లి అనాలేమో) ఏమిటో ఇతర రాష్ట్రాల తెలుగేతరులకు, ఇతర దేశీయులకు ఎలా తెలుస్తుంది?

If we go on writing our agitations in Telugu only, how do people of other States and other countries know?

अगर हम तॆलुगु मे लिखते लिखते समय बिताते जाय्, तो भारत का अन्य राज्यों के लोग को, दुनिया का अन्य देशों को लोगों को कैसा मालूम हो जायेगा?

104 Did Mr. Kejriwal fall into the pit dug by Congress. కాంగ్రెస్ త్రవ్విన గొయ్యిలో కేజ్రీవాల్ గారు పడ్డారా?

---

చర్చనీయాంశాలు: దేశ రాజకీయాలు, ఆం ఆద్మీ , కాంగ్రెస్

అరవింద్ కేజ్రీవాల్ గారు కాంగ్రెస్ తవ్వి న గుంటలో పడ్డట్లే లెక్క.


కాంగ్రెస్ , బిజెపీలు రెండు అవినీతి పార్టీలని కదా కేజ్రీవాల్ గారు చెప్పింది. ఇప్పుడు కాంగ్రెస్ తన వీపుపైన ఎక్కించుకొని కేజ్రీవాల్ గారిని మోయటానికి ముందుకు వచ్చినా, కేజ్రీవాల్ గారు వ్యామోహపడకుండా ఉండ వలసింది. ఎందుకంటే, వీపు మీద ఎక్కించుకునే వారు, ఎంతోకాలం బరువులను మోయలేరు. ఏదో ఒకరోజు నేలమీదకు త్రోసి వేయక తప్పదు.

గత కాలపు కాంగ్రెస్ మద్దతు చరిత్రను పరిశీలిస్తే, మధ్యలోనే క్రిందికి నెట్టేయటం మనకు స్పష్టంగా కనిపిస్తుంది. కాంగ్రెస్ చేత నెట్టివేయబడ్డ వాళ్ళలో చరణ్ సింగ్, చంద్రశేఖర్ లు, ప్రముఖులు. చరణ్ సింగ్ , చంద్రశేఖర్ లు, కాంగ్రెస్ కు ఎన్నడూ ఛాలెజర్లు గా మారలేదు. అయినా కాంగ్రెస్ వారిని నలిపేయటానికి వెనకాడలేదు.

కెజ్రీవాల్ ఎజెండా ఏమిటి? అఖిలభారత స్థాయిలో బిజేపీ కాంగ్రెస్ లను ఛాలెంజ్ చేయటం. దీనిని కాంగ్రెస్ ఎలా సహిస్తుంది. అవకాశం చూసుకొని దొంగ దెబ్బ తీస్తుంది.

ఆంధ్ర ప్రదేశ్ లో గవర్నర్ రామ్ లాల్, నాదెండ్ల భాస్కరరావు , కాంగ్రెస్, కలసి ఎన్ టీ ఆర్ ను దెబ్బతీసి నట్లుగా ఆమ్ ఆద్మీ పార్టీని కాంగ్రెస్ చీల్చటం, భవిష్యత్ దర్శనం. పదవీ వ్యామోహ పరులు సర్వత్రా ఉంటారు.

బిజేపీ, ఆప్ లు ప్రభుత్వాన్ని ఏర్పాటు చేయకపోతే, ఢల్లిలో రాష్ట్రపతి పాలన రావటం, తిరిగి ఎన్నికలకు ఎంతో ఖర్చు అవటం నిజమే అయినా, దానికి బాధ్యత వహించ వలసినది ప్రజలే. అది బ్రిటీష్ పార్లమెంటరీ పధ్ధతిని మనం అనుకరించటం వల్ల వచ్చిన ప్రమాదం.

ఒక పరిష్కారం: ఢిల్లీ శాసనసభ్యులు రహస్యబ్యాలెట్ ద్వారా ముఖ్యమంత్రిని, ఇతరమంత్రులను (శాఖలతో సహా) ఎన్నుకునే పధ్ధతి ప్రవేశ పెట్టటం అవసరం. అవసరం అయితే, దీని కొరకు రాజ్యాంగ సవరణలు చేసుకొని మనం ముందుకు వెళ్ళాలి. ఐదేళ్ల శాసన సభా పదవీకాలంలో, ఇలాంటి ఎన్నికలను రెండున్నర ఏళ్ళకొకసారి జరుపుకుంటే సరిపోతుంది. అవసరం అయితే ఇంకా ఎక్కువ సార్లు కూడ ఇలాటి ఎన్నికలను జరుపుకోవచ్చు.