682, Senior Leaders have to maintain decency. They can't be petty!!!

Mr. Venkaiah Naidu, Union Minister for Parliamentary Affairs, Union Minister for Urban Development, is a very Senior BJP Leader, and a Former President of BJP. He has a very sharp tongue. It may help him to occupy cushy positions, and his party for creating hurtful noises against its opponents. It does not help the Nation in any way. It does not reflect the character of an All India level intellectual. Of course, sometimes, it may have some nuissance value, like the writings of this ybrao-a-donkey.

Mr. Venkaiah Naidu is reported to have advised Kanhayah Kumar, the Student Leader of the Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) as under:-- Link: Click to go to Deccanchronicle.com.

"...They must study and stay away from politics. If they are interested in politics, they can leave studies and join politics. He can join any political party. His favourite party is now in single digit in the Parliament. Let him join that party. ..."

ybrao-a-donkey's humble comments. वैबीराव एक गधे के विनम्र राय . వైబీరావ్ గాడిద వినమ్ర వాణి. You have every right to differ with me. I respect your right. आपको मेरे मत से भिन्न राय रखने के संपूर्ण हक है। मै उस अधिकार को परिपूर्ण रूप से गौरव देता हुँ. మీకు, మీ భిన్నమైన అభిప్రాయాన్ని కలిగిఉండే సంపూర్ణ హక్కు ఉంది. దానిని ఎంతో నేను గౌరవిస్తాను. However, pl. examine this donkey's views also. परन्तु एस गधे के दृष्टिकोण को भी अनुशीलन कीजिये. కానీ ఈ గాడిద దృష్టికోణాన్ని కూడ ఓర చూపుతో కంటజూడుమీ, క్రీగంట జూడమీ.

The advice and suggestions of Mr. Venkaiah Naidu should apply to the A.B.V.P. also. Will Mr. Venkaiah Naidu dare to give this advice to ABVP?

In 1984, BJP was also a single digit party with in Lok Sabha, with just two MPs. Fortunes of Parties vary depending upon on a number of factors. The manner in which Indian Economy is being managed, even BJP can become a single digit party by 2019. In fact it is the dissatisfaction of the People of India with the Economic Management of this Nation by the UPA, they have taught a lesson to Congress by bringing BJP to power. This does not mean that BJP and its allies will be voted to power for ever. As a Senior leader, Mr. Venkaiah Naidu ought to realise this.

In India, elections involve spending of billions. Left Parties cannot mobilise such billions. Unless damn sure that Left Parties are going to win, Industrialists will not fund Left Parties. It will be a harakiri for Left Parties to accept funds from Industrialists. Such an act goes against the very basic philosophy of Socialism and Marxism.

Besides, people have a fetish for bourgeoisie parties. Indian voters are corrupt and lazy. Yet, a day may come when people realise their mistakes. In reality, there should be competition among Left Parties to win over Indian voters. Sadly enough, Left Parties in India today have become "tails" of bourgeoisie Parties.

Mr. Venkaiah Naidu hails from Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana. How many seats does his party get in Residual Andhra Pradesh in Telangana? In both the States it rode piggy-back on Telugu Desam Party. What advice will he give to ABVP Leaders of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, because BJP is a single DIGIT Party in both the States? Even in Delhi, BJP is a single digit Party!!!

Mr. Venkaiah Naidu himself migrated to neighboring Karnataka, to get a Rajya Sabha seat. Now, BJP leaders are said to be thinking of exporting him to Madhya Pradesh.

The role of Mr. Venkaiah Naidu in helping Mr. Narendra Modi and Mr. Arun Jaitley, to ditch the stalwarts of BJP, Mr. L.K. Advani and Mr. Murli Manohar Joshi is well-known.

The role of Mr. Venkaiah Naidu in the forced bisection of the United State of Andhra Pradesh, by making false promises of Special Status, Railway Zone, Polavaram Project, Fillingup budget revenue deficit, New Railway Zone, etc. etc. are well known. For all those never-realised promises, he accepted some felicitations also, funded by industrialists.

MINDSET OF LEADERS BOURGEOISIE PARTIES

Leaders of "Land-lord" Parties, and "Industrialist" Parties, can never understand the problems of the Deprived Sections and Classes. Apart from our leaders, most of our bureaucrats, judges, professionals, business persons, hail from LANDLORD and INDUSRIALIST Sections. They will joyfully co-operate with politicians, in continuing the oppression of poorer Sections in the Society.

Evils of the Society, are just seeping into the Universities. If the evils of the Society, outside the Universities can be rectified, there will be an automatic change in the environment of our Universities.

Mr. Kanhaya Kumar is in his youth. He does not know what is what. He needs guidance. But, the problem with today's youth is, they do not tolerate any guidance from others. Consequently, they will believe whatever they want to believe. 99% do not realise the consequences of what they do and what they canvass. By the time they realise that their perceptions were false, their physical activity slows down.

Subject to substantial Revision, additions and deletions. To continue and revise this, with more proof.. सशेष. సశేషం.

468 What work do Coolies have in forests in the Seshachalam forests of Chittoor District?- Urban Development Minister.

468 కూలీలకు అడవిలో ఏం పని , అని మన నగరాభివృధ్ధి కేంద్ర మంత్రి గారు అన్నారుట
468 What work do Coolies have in forests in the Seshachalam forests of Chittoor District?- Urban Development Minister.
468 चित्तूर जिले शेषाचलं अरण्य में मजदूरों को क्या काम है? -केंद्र नगराभिवृध्धि मंत्रीजी.

The following comment is being attributed to Mr. Venkaiah Naidu, Union Urban Development and Parliamentary Affairs Minister.

Don't the coolies know that cutting down red sanders trees is a crime?  Do they go for work without knowing what kind of job it is?  क्या कूलियों को पता नहीं कि, रक्त चंदन पेडों को काटना एक अपराध है ?  क्या वे अपने काम के बारे में समाचार के बिना काम को जाते? రక్త చందనం చెట్లను కొట్టటం నేరమని కూలీలకు తెలీదా?  తాము చేయాల్సిన పని ఎలాటిదో తెలీకుండానే వారు పనికి వెళ్తారా?

If what is attributed above in Media is true, then we must consider Mr. Venkaiah Naidu as ignorant of workers behavior.  अगर मीडिया वार्ता कथन सच हो, तो हम श्री वॆंकय्या नायुडू को श्रामिक बर्ताव के बारे में अज्ञानी मानना होगा ।  మీడియా లో వచ్చిన పై వార్త నిజమే అయితే మనం శ్రీ వెంకయ్యనాయుడు గారిని శ్రామికుల ప్రవర్తన విషయంలో అజ్ఞానిగా భావించాల్సి వస్తుంది.

Why?  Mr. Venkaiah Naidu hails from a rural area in Andhra Pradesh.  The area lies on the borders of forests.  Villagers on the borders of forests eke out their living by collecting firewood, forest products etc.  For many of them, particularly illiterate laborers, it is almost a daily chore.  Some of them may already know that it is a crime to cut red sanders trees.  Some of them may also know that it was highly risky to venture into forests for livelihood.  At the same time, every villager in backward Districts is not a B.A., B.L., like Mr. Naidu.  Even Mr. Venkaiah Naidu as a lawyer, may not know all the laws, every Section in every Act, with added amendments, notifications etc. 


Even if the labourers know, they cannot avoid going to forests because woodcutting was a thousands of years old, very ancient occupation, since the days of man being a hunter.  Consequently, going to forests for collecting wood and forest produce became a human right.  Governments considering that forest trees as their State property, auctioning the trees to benefit forest contractors etc. were developments of later Centuries.  Of course, cutting red sanders or smuggling it may not be a human right.  But then, the State will have to make a distinction between the smugglers and woodcutters.


The object of this particular blog post is not-- to defend the red sanders smugglers, or their heinous act of killing forest Officials.  The criminals who killed the Forest and Police Officials earlier are definitely to be caught and punished appropriately.  If necessary, in self defence, police may have to use fire weapons against them.


The 20 wood-cutter labourers who died (may be smugglers or their assistants) are not likely to be the above criminals.  Now , the murderer criminals are still to be searched and 302 cases are to be booked against the smuggler mafia gang leaders.  This encounter is not a substitute for that.  Both are separate things.  Both the batches of smugglers/laborers are separate groups.


Living in dire poverty, some wood-cutters of Tamil Nadu might have been tempted to accept the work in Seshachalam, when they were offered double or higher wages than the wages paid to ordinary wood-cutters.


These are the days, when film stars who have already earned millions of bucks, who have received Padma Bhushans and Padma VibhUshans, Rajya Sabha Memberships,  may again and again expose every private part of theirs and dance obscenely, if they get more bucks. 

Is there any wonder, in laborers (they may not be innocent) accepting the work, without knowing the dire risk of getting  fired fatally?  They might have thought that they would go to jail if caught.  Or the mafia leaders might have assured them that they will arrange bail, appoint a lawyer, maintain their families while in jail, etc.  Of course, the laborers believing the words of the smuggler mafia lost their lives, for taking an undue risk for a few more bucks.

It is also a different thing that A.P. Govt. or Tamil Nadu Government pays them some compensation.  After all, the politicians or the Officials do not pay the compensation from their pockets.  The amounts will be paid from exchequer. 


Besides , compensation is not a substitute for loss of lives.   When a physical laborer dies, a Nation loses his productivity for 30 years ie. for 9000 days, nearly Rs. 4.5 million.  A Nation which takes pride in its young population, its productivity, should not throw away their lives, unless there are unavoidable circumstances.   These unavoidable circumstances are to be checked now.


Some pertinent questions which arise:

1. The Police and Forest authorities claim that "Shoot at sight" orders have been passed and publicised. 

a) Have sign boards of large size placed on FOREST PATHS in Tamil and Telugu languages, warning about the RISK OF BEING SHOOT ON SIGHT?

b) Have the "shoot at sight" orders been repeatedly beamed ON TV CHANNELS in Tamil and Telugu languages in Andhra Pradesh, and the neighboring Districts of Tamil Nadu?

c) Have sufficient number printed pamphlets been printed in Tamil and Telugu languages and distributed in the A.P. and T.N. border districts?

d) Have Panchayats and Municipalities of the area been informed of the SHOOT AT SIGHT ORDERS?

e) Now-a-days both the Central and State Governments send a number of mobile SMSes even for flimsy things.  Did they send any such "SMS" messages about SHOOT AT SIGHT ORDERS to any mobiles in Chittoor, Cuddapah and the adjacent Districts in Tamil Nadu?

f) Did they show any slides or short-films in the local cinema halls, about the Shoot at Sight Orders?

g) Did they make sufficient number of announcements on loud speakers, before resorting to fire?

h) Why didn't they try firing into sky, firing at legs, before resorting to direct fire?  Are there are any special circumstances for skipping the first two prerequisites?

i) Did they exhibit some RED WARNING BOARDS at Lorry & Mini Lorry stands, auto stands to warn the laborers?

j) Did they announce it All India Radio Stations of Cuddapah, Chennai?  In All India Radio, every hour we hear an advertisement "I am Narendra Modi.  etc. etc. "  The SHOOT AT SIGHT ORDERS could have been repeatedly announced on All India Radio.

Police and Forest Officials have every right to fire against attackers in self-defence.  But the question is: Is this right being exercised honestly and sincerely?  Are there any circumstances to believe that this right has been exercised honestly and sincerely?  This should now be checked through a judicial process.  If the Police and Forest Officials can show that they have followed the above precautions, they can expect full public support for their actions from public.

Normally, Police, Forest, Excise Officials do not move, when people approach them with complaints.  Bribes are necessary both to initiate an action which they are bound to take as per law, and to stop an action which they have started. 

There may be a strong desire on the part of the Police, Forest officials to take revenge against smugglers who have killed two innocent Officers discharging their duties.  But is this desire, a sufficient motivation to fire on a very large scale?

There are news reports that political leaders of the area have links with the smugglers, and that some of the political leaders themselves are the smugglers.  The Police and Forest Officials should have started their combing with the politicians and their cronies, by repeated inspections of their residences, factories, godowns, cattle sheds, plantations etc.  Let the Police and Forest Officials publish a list of politicians, industrialists, business persons, whose houses, factories, godowns, cattle sheds, plantations etc. they have searched, and the number of cases they have registered.  How many cases of disproportionate wealth in relation to sources of income they noticed during the searches, and what action they have initiated against the top king pins of the racket?

Justice should not only be done, but should also appear to have been done. 

Conclusion

Till India attains full employment in its true sense, coolies may have work with forests.  They will not have any work with angels (deva dUtAs).

(To continue.  सशेष.  ఇంకా ఉంది.)

333 Bowls pass on from one genertion to another generation.

333 Bowls pass on from one genertion to another generation.
333 తాతల నాటి బొచ్చెలు తరతరాలు.
३३३ टूटी कटोरे एक पीढी से दूसरा पीढी को (एक संतति से दुसरे संतति को) साँपा जाते हैँ।
चर्चांश, Topics for discussion, చర్చనీయాంశాలు: 333,BJP,బిజెపి, भाजपा, वॆंकय्य नायुडु, अदवानी, जोषी, वाजपेयी, मोडी

---

Read the auspicious quotes of Shri Venkaiah Naidu.Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:శ్రీ వెంకయ్యనాయుడు గారి సుభాషితాలు చదవండి.Hindi Gist हिन्दी संग्रह: श्री वॆंकय्या नायुडू जी के सुभाषित पढीये।

“...we are a democratic party and a new generation of leaders is given an opportunity to come up to the leadership levels. That does not mean others are sidelined or ignored,...”

"...Recasting of the parliamentary board a generational shift, giving young blood more responsibilities..."

In Telugu language, we have a proverb, which reads tAtala nAti bochche tara tarAlu. తెలుగు భాషలో తాతల నాటి బొచ్చె తరతరాలు అనే సామెత ఉంది. तॆलुगु भाषा में एक उक्ती है कि: तातल नाटि बॊच्च तरतरालु.

One middle aged son used to feed his old father in a broken bowl, scanty meal, ill-treating him all the time. Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:ఒక మధ్య వయస్కుడైన కొడుకు తన వృధ్ధతండ్రిని ఒక చిల్లి బొచ్చెలో చాలీ చాలని అన్నాన్ని, తిడుతూ తినిపించే వాడు. Hindi Gist हिन्दी संग्रह: एक मध्य वयस्क बेटा अपने पिता को एक टुटे हुए कटोरें में बहुत कम और खराबी खाना , गालियाँ देते हुए खिलाता था।

One day grand son asked his father, "why are you feeding grandfather in a broken bowl, filled with stale and inadequate food?" Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం: ఒక రోజు మనమడు తండ్రిని అడిగాడు. "నీవు తాతయ్యకి ఎందుకు ఆ చిల్లి బొచ్చెలో పాసిపోయిన, చాలీ చాలని అన్నం పెట్తున్నావు?", అని. Hindi Gist हिन्दी संग्रह: एक दिन पोते ने अपने पिते को पूछा। "आप दादे को टूटी हुई कटोरे में खराबी खाना बहुत अपर्याप्त मात्रा में क्यों खिला रहे हैँ?

The middle aged father replied: "It is our custom and tradition. Understand!" Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:ఆ మధ్య వయస్కుడైన కొడుకు మనమడికి ఇలాచెప్పాడు. "అది మన వంశాచారం. సాంప్రదాయం. మనం దానిని గౌరవించి తీరాలి. అర్ధం అయ్యిందా!!" वह मध्य वयस्क बेटा, पोते को बोला कि: "वह है, हमारा वंशाचार. हमारा सांप्रदायिकता. समझ गया ना!!"

Grandson: "Understood! Father!". Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:మనుమడు: "అర్ధం అయ్యింది!!Hindi Gist हिन्दी संग्रह: నాన్నా!!". पोता: "समझ गया !! बापूजी !!"

Next day, the middleaged son found that the young boy was chiseling a broken bowl to make its hole larger. Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:మర్నాడు ఆ మధ్యవయస్కుడైన తండ్రి, ఆ కుర్రాడు ఒక సుత్తి ఉలి తీసుకొని ఒక బొచ్చెకు చిల్లిని పెట్టటానికి టపటపా కొట్టటాన్ని చూశాడు. Hindi Gist हिन्दी संग्रह: अगले दिन उस मध्य वयस्क आदमी उस छोटे पोते को, एक छेनी से एक पुरानी कटोरी को सूराख काटने के लिये मारने को देखा।

That middle aged man, exclaiming, asked the young lad. "Why are you hammering that bowl to make a hole?" . Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:ఆ మధ్య వయస్కుడు, ఆశ్చర్యపోతూ, ఆ యువకుడిని అడిగాడు. "నీవు ఎందుకా బొచ్చెకు చిల్లి పెట్టటానికి సుత్తితో కొట్తున్నావు?" Hindi Gist हिन्दी संग्रह:उस मध्य वयस्क आदमी उस छोटे पोते को पूछा कि: "तुम उस कटोरॆ को हथोडी से क्यों छेद बनाने के लिये हथोडी से टुटा रहे हो?

Grandson replied. "It is our clan's custom. It is our tradition. We should respect our customs and traditions. It is our sacred duty!! I am getting the bowl ready for you." Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:మనుమడు జవాబిచ్చాడు: "అది మన వంశాచారం. అది మన సాంప్రదాయం. మనం దానిని గౌరవించాలి. నాన్నగారూ అది మన పవిత్ర కర్తవ్యం!! ఈ చిల్లి బొచ్చెను నేను నీకోసమే తయారు చేస్తున్నాను." पोते ने जवाब दिया: "वह है हमारा वंशाचार । वह है हमारा सांप्रदायिकता । हम हमारे परंपरा और परिपाटी को समादर करना हमारा पवित्र कर्तव्य है ना !! मै इस कटोरी को आप के लिये अत्यंत निपुणता से तय्यार कर रहा हुँ। "

Respected Shri Venkaiahji, Are you listening. When did BJP start this custom, tradition and sacred duty? Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:గౌరవనీయ వెంకయ్యాజీ, వింటున్నారా? బిజెపి ఈ ఆచారాన్ని, సాంప్రదాయాన్ని, పవిత్ర కర్తవ్యాన్ని ఎపుడు ప్రారంభించింది? मान्य श्री वॆंकय्या महोदय, आप सुन रहे है? बिजॆपी इस परंपरागत परिपाटी को और पवित्र कर्तव्य को मानना कब शुरू किया?

ybrao-a-donkey's feelings వైబీరావు గాడిద మనోభావాలు वैबीरावु गधे के मनोभाव

Removing Vajpayee, Advani, Murali Manohar Joshi in one stroke, from BJP Parliamentary Board is very cruel. This is not an unforeseen eventuality. Modi Amit Shah Rajnath Jaitley & Co should have discussed with the Great Old Men. After all, in our country of great culture, Yudhishthira (Dharmaraja) went to Bhishma pitAmaha and asked him the ways and means of killing him in the battle, who advised him to place Sikhandi before Arjuna on his chariot.

Telugu gist, తెలుగు సారం:వాజపేయీ, అద్వానీ, మురళీమనోహర్ జోషీ లను, ధనాధన్ బిజెపి పార్లమెంటరీ బోర్డునుండి తొలగించటం చాల క్రూరం. ఇది ఊహించనిది కాదు. మోడీ అమీత్ షా రాజనాథ్ సింగ్ జైట్లీ & కో ఆవృధ్ధనేతలతో చర్చించి ఉంటే బాగుండేది. మన ఘనాఘన భారతీయ సంస్కృతి ప్రకారం, మహాభారత యుధ్దంలో ధర్మరాజు తాత భీష్ముడి దగ్గరికి వెళ్ళి తాతా నిన్ను ఎట్లా చంపటం అని అడిగాడు. భీష్మ పితామహుడు శిఖండిని అర్జునుడి ముందు పెట్టుకుని యుధ్ధానికి రమ్మని సలహా ఇచ్చాడు.

वाजपेयी, अद्वानी, मुरली मनोहर जोषी को बिजॆपी पार्लमॆंटरी बोर्ड से धनाधन निकालना, बहुत नृशंस और अमानवीय है। परन्तु, यह अपूर्वद्रष्ट नहीं है। मोडी अमीत षा राजनाथ जैट्ली & को इस बात को पितामहों से परिष्कार पूछना, और इंतजार करना था। हमारे घनाघन भारतीय संस्कृती के अनुसार, महाभारत युध्ध में युधिष्ठिर भिष्म पितामह के सामने जाकर उन से उपाय केलिये पूछा कि: हम आप को किस कार्यनीती से मार सकते है. भीष्म पितामह ने जवाब दिया: "शिखंडी को अर्जुन के रथ में सामने बिठाकर आना।"